Print this page.
Articles Online
Summary
Just as Juma prayers are offered within 12 to 15 hours around the globe, beginning and end of Ramazan and other months and eid prayers occur within the same time constraint  – and not with the gap of one to three days.  As earth's mass is 81 times and diameter 4 times greater than moon, the moon becomes visible in South Asian Region a day or two later than K'aba. Holy Prophet (sws) laid great emphasis on unity of Ummah. It is simply illogical to believe that he wanted that different months of Islamic calendar begin and end in different cities and countries on different weekdays with a gap of one to three days and/or having a month of 29 days in one country and the same month same year having 30 days in another! By regarding the appearance of crescent at K'aba as start of new month for the whole globe, we can easily achieve unification of Islamic calendar.
It was the logically correct interpretation of Muslim scholars of 10th century during the reign of Fatmid caliphs in Egypt that the advice of the Holy Prophet to start and end fasting by looking at the crescent was meant for people of that age as there were no printed calendars. And the use of Islamic Hijri calendar based on astronomical calculations came into advent in 10th century in order to maintain uniformity in the growing Muslim communities in different countries and continents. However, the orthodoxy of Saudi Arabia insisted and still insists on  visibility of crescent by naked eye at Ka’ba in Mecca. 

A Global Islamic Calendar based on astronomical calculations for appearance of crescent in Mecca is the best way to standardize Islamic dating procedures. Click here for the full article

Islamic Calendar
by Shah N. Khan

For the last several years Organization of Islamic Countries (OIC)  has been trying in vain  to prescribe a uniform basis for determining the onset of new month or year under Islamic Lunar calendar which at present begin on different days of the week in different countries depending upon sighting of the new crescent on earth in their region and often difference of a day or two takes place. The mass of the earth is 81 times and diameter 4 times greater than the moon. The date and time of each New Moon can be computed exactly by astronomers but the time that the crescent first becomes visible to naked eye on earth after the New Moon depends on many factors and cannot be predicted with certainty. 

Only a few countries, organizations like Fiqh Council of North America and  communities like Bohras rely totally on an astronomical lunar calendar for Islamic months without any need of actual sighting the waxing crescent with naked eye. Most often the month of Ramadan commences according to that calendar one or two days ahead of actual visibility of the crescent in South Asian countries though it may be visible in some parts of the globe. 

In a few countries like Saudi Arabia and Pakistan  a  committee appointed by the Government decides or recommends whether or not the new moon has been sighted. In India and other Non-Muslim countries the Muslim religious leaders declare whether or not new month has begun and more often than not such important festivals as Eid, Birth Anniversaries of the Holy Prophet (sws) are held on different days of the week with a gap of a day or two as Muslims are divided in three broad groups:

(a) Largest one indulges in ritual of crescent sighting on regional basis on every 29th day of the Hijri month. See the note about Saudi practice below.

(b) Second largest one follows the announcement at Mecca based on sighting of crescent by naked eye at Holy Ka'ba.

(c) Followers of Egyptian or the modern astronomical Hijri Calendar who look at the printed calendar instead of the skies. And this group is also divided among those who prepare the calendar in advance based on astronomical data for a particular region and the other that indicates first appearance of crescent anywhere on the earth..

According to recent reports the OIC plans to launch an $8-million satellite within two years to take pictures of the moon to find lunar calendar dates.  It said religious scholars would have access to accurate pictures of  the shape of the moon instead of having to rely on naked-eye sightings which have in the past created discrepancies between Muslim countries or mistakes. Few years ago a moon sighting committee in Saudi Arabia, had shocked millions of worshippers when it said it got the date wrong by a day for the Haj pilgrimage.

The OIC will fund the project, which was conceived by Cairo University's Space Science Center. "The satellite will have a fixed camera on board that will take highly-detailed pictures of the moon and beam them back to earth," said Professor Mervat Awad, the center's director.The satellite, which is being built by an Italian firm, would also be used to research asteroids, Awad added.

It was not immediately clear how many countries would use the technology to determine religious dates. There is already some criticism from religious scholars in Saudi Arabia, which for civil purposes uses the lunar calendar. known as the Umm al-Qura calendar developed at the King Abdulaziz City for Science and Technology (KACST) in Riyadh based on the modern astronomical data.  It is only for civil purposes but for important occasions such as Holy Ramadan, Haj etc. the practice of seeing the crescent with naked eye from Mecca, or more precisely, from the Great Mosque of Mecca (al-masjid al-haram) where the Ka'ba and the holy Black Stone (al-hajar al-aswad) are located - is being followed. And on the recommendations of Ulemas the Government declares the festivals or special occasions and adjust the calendar. As of 1423 AH (15 March 2002) onwards, the Institute of Astronomical & Geophysical Research has modified its rules for the Umm al-Qura calendar as follows:

If on the 29th day of the lunar month the two following conditions are satisfied, then the next day is the first day of the new lunar month: 
(a) The geocentric conjunction occurs before sunset. 
(b) The Moon sets after the Sun. 
Otherwise, the current lunar month will last 30 days.

"The shape of the moon has to be seen from the ground," said Osama al-Bar, dean of the Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques Institute for Haj Research in Saudi Arabia. Bigotry and close minded approach is evident from the following quote:

""The earth is flat, and anyone who disputes this claim is an atheist who deserves to be punished."_ Sheik Abdel-Aziz Ibn Baaz, Supreme religious authority, Saudi Arabia and author of a Muslim religious edict, 1993: 

The Islamic calendar is based on the lunar year and consists of 354 or 355 days. The number of days in each month is adjusted throughout the year in accordance with each lunar cycle. The beginning of the Muslim year retrogresses through the solar year, completing a full cycle every 32 1/2 years.

Months Number of Days
Muharram 29 or 30
Safar 29 or 30
Rabi I 29 or 30
Rabi II 29 or 30
Jumada I 29 or 30
Jumada II 29 or 30
Rajab 29 or 30
Sha`ban 29 or 30
Ramadan 29 or 30
Shawwal 29 or 30
Dhu'l-Qa`dah 29 or 30
Dhu'l-Hijjah 29 or 30

Hijri Calendar was first
introduced in 638 C.E. by a close companion of the Prophet and the second Caliph, `Umar ibn Al-KHaTTab (592-644 C.E.). He did it in an attempt to rationalize the various, at times conflicting, dating
systems used during his time. `

Umar consulted with his advisors on the starting date of the new Muslim chronology. It was finally agreed that the most appropriate reference point for the Islamic calendar was the _Hijrah_. The actual starting date for the Calendar was chosen (on the basis of purely lunar years, counting backwards) to be the first day of the first month (1 MuHarram) of the year of the Hijrah. The Islamic (Hijri) calendar (with dates that fall within the Muslim Era) is
usually abbreviated A.H. in Western languages from the latinized _Anno Hegirae_. MuHarram 1, 1 A.H. corresponds to July 16, 622 C.E.

The Hijrah, which chronicles the migration of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) from Makkah to Madinah in September 622 C.E., is the central historical event of early Islam. It led to the foundation of the first
Muslim city-state, a turning point in Islamic and world history.

The most important dates in the Islamic (Hijri) year 

MuHarram (Islamic new year); 

27 Rajab (Isra & Miraj); 

1 Ramadan (first day of fasting); 

17 Ramadan (Nuzul Al-Qur'an);

Last 10 days of Ramadan which include Laylatu al-Qadar; 

1 SHawwal (`iyd al-FiTr); 

8-10 Thw al-Hijjah (the Hajj to Makkah); 

and 10 Thw al-Hijjah (`iyd al-'aDHHae).



Related article
Excerpts and Notes from
Prof. Omar Afzal, Ph.D. 
about Hijri Calendar
 
 
 
 
Since the moon's diameter is almost one-fourth of the earth, it is unlikely that it would appear on all parts of the earth on the same day. The Islamic calendar developed during the reign of Fatmid Caliphs centuries ago in Egypt accurately coincides with appearance of new moon in one part of the Earth or the other and Bohra community and many other
communities and countries depend on that. Many Ulemas opine that sighting of moon in any part of the earth can be followed for fasting. But the majority view appears to be that the moon must be sighted in their own place or country..

Holy Quran merely prescribes lunar cycle for calendaring but does not make it necessary to see the moon with naked eye. Only a few Hadiths support the orthodox view that sighting is necessary. For instance the one narrated by Hazrat Abdullah bin Umar is translated as, "Allah's Apostle (PBUH) said, "The month (can be) 29 nights (i.e. days), and do not fast till you see the moon, and if the sky is overcast, then complete Sha'ban as thirty days."

But all such Hadiths tend to negate the need for formation of a Central committee for moon sighting  and may require us to leave every town and city to determine its own dates and timing as is done for prayers! If we can follow the sighting of moon at Northern Areas why can't we follow the dates at Ka'ba and avoid the ridiculous situation of Ist of
calendar month falling on different days of the week?

What is not realized is fact that the underlying principle of Hadith is also to consult lunar calendar. Viewed form another angle, Hadiths are third party narration and that advise was addressed to the people living in Mecca or Medina who used to determine dates by watching moon, as there were neither printed calendars and neither watches. The concept of minutes and seconds was unknown and people used to determine time by the shadows created by sunlight. 

The Hadiths about moon sighting are not as categorical and detailed as the Hadiths relating to Wadu and prayers timings and number of Rakats, Had it been intended to prescribe moon sighting each month for all times and all places it would have been specified in more details as prayer timings are. After all we depend on  watches to determine time for Sehar and Iftar whereas the Hadiths defines that in terms of movement of sun.

The Islamic calendar developed in Egypt accurately coincides with appearance of new moon in one part of the Earth or the other and many communities depend on that. Many Ulemas opine that sighting of moon in any part of the earth can be followed for fasting.  Let us hope and pray that OIC's efforts to prescribe a uniform basis for determining onset of new month and year under Islamic calendar succeed.

Prayers Timings are Regional but Juma & Eid Prayers and commencement of new months are Global

Just as Juma prayers are offered withing 12 to 15 hours all over the globe, the same should be the case with commencement of Ramazan or Eid or any other month or year. But alas differencen of one to three days occurs due to different interpretations.

The solution is simple and OIC should prescribe it:
Until consensus is reached about Islamic calendar's date line, all OIC countries may follow for the month of Holy Ramadan, the announcement of Saudi Arabia about moon sighting at Mecca with naked eye according the practice of Holy Prophet because Mecca is the center of the Islamic world and we are commanded to face toward Ka'ba for prayers. There are places on earth where crescent cannot be sighted for many months. 

For the sake of uniformity OIC countries can follow Umm al-Qura calendar as now it is based on the scientific and reliable data for appearance of waxing crescent at Mecca and it is  adjusted every year by determining onset and the end of Holy Month Ramadan based on actual crescent sighting in Mecca by naked eye. There is no need to do such adjustments every month. This is the easiest way at present to maintain uniformity in following the Hijri Islamic calendar. The central and Regional Ruyiet Hilal committees in Pakistan and other countries should be dissolved as their declaration often cause conflicts. . 

Night of Power
Due to difference of opinion in Interpreting the Hadiths usually Holy Ramadan starts on different days in different regions and countries. Sometimes the difference is more than one day. The question arises how this affects the Night of Power.

According to opinion of prominent Saudi Ulemas God is very kind to us. He does not place a burden on us as a result of the mistakes of our Ulemas or rulers. Should we make an error in the sighting of the moon and, as a result, begin Ramadan on the wrong date, He does not deprive us of any benefit of the month.

There will still be a Night of Power, and it will occur on an odd night in the last third of the month. Since we differ according to the sighting of the moon, the Night of Power will remain true according to our actual fasting. This means that it will occur on different days for different regions, but it will continue to be calculated by the same criterion.

In other words, in each community, it will be on their odd nights in the last ten days of the month. What is to be remembered in this connection is that God has made the Night of Power an occasion to earn great and rich reward, and He does not deprive His servants of such an occasion because of an error in calculating the start of their month. However, people are required to do their best in order to ascertain the right start of each lunar month, particularly Ramadan. 

Related Article
Origin of Islamic Calendar
http://www.netvert.biz/paklink/articles/calendar.html

Moon sighting and Islamic Calendar
Why Different Months begin from different days in different places and communities?
Why Can't We Celebrate Eidul Fitar on the same Day?
Is Moon sighting necessary? If yes where? 
See article at http://www.netvert.biz/paklink/articles/eid.html 

Astronomy of Islamic Calendar. Hijri calendar's History and usage
http://www.netvert.biz/paklink/articles/HijriCalendar.html 

The moon sighting suspense 
Comments on  a seminar organized jointly by the Pakistan  Academy 
of Sciences, the ministry of religious affairs, 
http://www.netvert.biz/paklink/articles/moon-suspense