Print this page.
Articles Online
.
 
Islamization of Economics
by Shah N. Khan

The fallacy of Islamization continues. Now proponents of
Islamic Economics are before us! Our people want to Islamize
everything except our own own character and vision! May be 
we will soon hear about Islamic Surgery, Islamic Logic, Islamic Navigation, Islamic Astronomy etc.

Undoubtedly, 
Islam is "Din-e-Kamil"
a perfect  religion and lays great stress acquisition of knowledge, hard work, honesty, justice, charity, kindness and brotherhood,  .
.
Undoubtedly, Islam is "Din-e-Kamil" a perfect  religion and 
lays great stress acquisition of knowledge, hard work, honesty, justice, charity, kindness and brotherhood. Islam is also "Din-e-Fitrat", a religion of the nature as its laws and commandments are in conformity with laws of nature. Islam is a complete code of life for salvation and welfare of mankind in this world and afterlife. There, is nothing in Holy Quran which can
be regarded as contrary to the scientific findings.
Maurice BucailIe in his book "Bible, Quran and Science"
has stated many natural phenoma have been described
and none of the findings of the modern science contradict
that description. But Holy Quran is not a book of science. 
It is supposed  to be a book of guidance not only for Muslim 
but the entire humanity. In fact the Holy Quran goes
to the extent of saying that All Men are a Single Nation.
Maurice BucailIe in his book "Bible, Quran and Science" has stated many natural phenoma have been described and none of the findings of the modern science 
contradict
that description. 

 

..
Economics is a social science concerned with the
production, distribution, exchange, and consumption of
goods and services. Economists focus on the way in
which individuals, groups, business enterprises, and
governments achieve economic objectives efficiently.

Economics is divided into two major fields. The first,
microeconomics, explains how the interplay of supply
and demand in competitive markets creates a multitude
of individual prices, wage rates, profit margins, and
 rental changes. The second field, macroeconomics,
deals with explanations of national income and employment.

Like all other man-made sciences economics remains
imperfect and that prompts the great thinkers to say:

If all economists were laid end to end, they would not
reach a conclusion._George Bernard Shaw 

In our time, the curse is monetary illiteracy, just as
inability to read plain print was the curse of earlier
centuries. Ezra Pound, U.S. poet, critic.

The day is not far off when the economic problem will
take the back seat where it belongs, and the arena of
the heart and the head will be occupied or reoccupied,
by our real problems-the problems of life and of human
 relations, of creation and behaviour and religion.
_John Maynard Keynes (1883-1946), British economist.

But it appears that the proponent of Islamic Economics
do not themselves know how the Islamic Economics would
differ with the conventional science of economics.
However, they are certainly correct about applicability of Islamic code of ethics to economic activities at all levels. Holy Prophet
(sws) himself set an example of principles of trading and honest
dealings and disclosure of full facts. In Islam the maximu 'Let the buyer be Beware" does not apply. It is moral obligation of the seller to disclose the defects of his product rather than hiding them.

In the fifth century there was widespread belief among the
Christians that the Lord Jesus prohibits Interest and it was banished in many countries. There are moral standards in Bible also. Will that produce Christian Economics?

The concept of Islamic system as some zealots of Islamization of
economics appears to be more like Utopian philosophy inasmuch as they regard alleviation of poverty by fair and equitable
distribution of wealth as an objective of Islamic system! Although there is great emphasis on charity and helping the needy and
payment of Zakat and distribution of war booty,  there is no
provision in Holy scriptures for distributing of wealth and ownership on socialist pattern, 

The research on Islamic Banking has been going on for years. 
But neither its parameters have properly been defined nor any concrete practical steps taken to evolve the standards, procedures, and to educate the people. Only Arabic terminology is used
to describe old trading practices.

The fact remains that banking is banking - and economics is economics - whatever name you may give it according to the policies and practices adopted.

There are a number of commandments and prohibitions in
Holy Quran and the sayings of the Holy Prophet (saws)
regarding various financial matters and the manner in
which the business is to be conducted.  They relate to
Zakat, bequests and inheritance, rights of widows and
orphans, blood-money, trusts, compensation for work,
virtues of charity, spending in the way of Allah for
welfare or help of the poor and needy, slavery,
trade, weights and measures, loans, trusts, contracts,
prohibition for professional beggary, misrepresentation,
profiteering and hoarding etc.  All these must be
followed in developing economic policies and practices
and modifying the conventional banking and monetary
practices.

We talk about abolishing interest from our banking system
without realizing that it would be like putting the cart before
the horse. We will have to switch over to a monetary system
under which the purchasing power of currency does not decline
such as that based on pure gold standard. But We are following 
a monetary system of paper money issued under the Government 
edict without any backing by  gold or other commodity. 

Prior to 1970 the paper currency used to be backed by gold but 
after the Arabs started using oil as a weapon the IMF in 1970 
abandoned gold standard altogether for the currencies and prescribed rules that the members must follow the managed currency system without any commodity backing which according to some economists facilitate in marinating economic hegemony of G7 countries who  exploit the exchange rates to their advantage.

The Supreme Court has ruled to abolish Interest and had
allowed one more year to the Government to take measure 
for  interest free banking. However, this decision has been
revoked by the Supreme Court on the appeal of the 
Government through one of its bank and the case has been
remanded for further study of inflation etc. In this regard 
please see the article

In 1948 by the father of the Nation Quiade Azam had advised to
modify the monetary system but State Bank has ignore his
advice due to the needs of the rulers for paper money and now  after 53 years we find ourselves back in square one with our
Rupee regressed to paisa level and the coins of Annas and Pie
are gone leaving us with a grossly mismanaged and beleaguered economy and heavy burden of foreign debts.  Many Governments have come and gone but none had the will and conviction to
implement the Quaid's advice. On the contrary each ruler had their own share in robbing its own citizens, wittingly or unwittingly, in a manner as described by Maynard Keynes (1883-1946), British economist.

"By a continuing process of inflation governments
 can confiscate, secretly and unobserved, an
 important part of the wealth of their citizens."

 In the 7th century AD at the time of dawn of Islam,
 money consisted of metallic coins and gold and silver
 bars. That was the kind of money whose purchasing
 power was not only stable but also tended to
 appreciate, like the worth of land or gold. It
 was and still is the simplest and straightforward
 method of fulfilling the promise of the Rulers who
 issue coins and currency to give you the real worth of
 the money - not less than what you acquired when you
 took that money in your custody. In this respect
 our Governments have been guilty of breach of the
 trust, as it is incumbent upon the rulers, according
 to Islamic precepts to protect the interests of his
 people. There is need for evolving standard by Ijtehad
 for linking of currency to gold or some other
 commodity and printing of notes according to the
 reserves needed  for stability of the currency.


 
We talk about abolishing interest from our banking system
without realizing that it would be like putting the cart before the horse. First we will have to switch over to a monetary system
under which the purchasing power of currency does not decline. But We are following a monetary system of paper currency issued under the Government  edict without any backing of   gold or other commodity. 

Prior to 1970 the paper currency used to be backed by gold but 
after the Arabs started using oil as a weapon the IMF in 1970 
abandoned gold standard altogether for the currencies and prescribed rules that the members must follow the managed currency system without any commodity backing which according to some economists
facilitate in marinating economic hegemony of G7 countries who
 exploit the exchange rates to their advantage.
 

.
 
 There is a fallacy prevailing among our people that
 merely by abandoning the interest as charged in the
 modern banking and financial institutions we can find
 solution to our economic problems. We have been
 spending more Foreign Exchange than that we earn. Our
 Government has been spending more money than it
 collects in taxes etc. and prints paper currency
callously. Our real problem is chronic inflation. And
 its root cause has not been addressed properly. A good
 monetary system would not by itself solve our economic
 problems. But the existing monetary system makes us
 the sitting target for exploitation.

If we want to achieve prosperity, we must modernize 
agriculture, pay greater attention to industrial and techonoligical
knowhow, adopt culture of merit and justice and honesty, 
eliminate corruption and graft and modify the
monetary system. We must also pay taxes, catch the
thieves who steal power and other resources, nab the
corrupt workers and bureaucrats, dishonest businessman
and increase gross domestic output, export more than
we import and adopt the Islamic virtues of honesty,
hard work, fair and equitable dealing in all walks
of life and educate the masses, build more schools,
colleges, hospitals and factories, improve efficiency
and productivity, earn living by honest means, make
the Rizq Halal by honest days work, and keep on
 improving our knowledge and skills.